NOTE: We are limiting each group to approximately 10 people per investigation and masks will be required until lifted by the state of Indiana. Scheduled investigation dates may be subject to change if the state imposes strict travel guidelines. We will work to make every effort to accommodate changes if they should arise.

The Historic Fowler Theater is known for its beautifully restored Art Deco look and feel, but beyond the ornate, outward appearance, there is a history of mysterious noises, shadows and strange activity.

The old Benton County Jail once held Jacob Nelling, a man accused of brutally murdering at 15 year old girl. Jacob never got his time in court as a group of men decided his fate after storming the jail and dragging him to a short distance from the home of the murdered girl where he was hanged for all to see.

Investigation Rates and Information:

NEW OFFERING! (Theater or Jail):

  • $150 for an investigation up to 6 people for 3 hours only
  • $25 per person for every additional person over 6 people

One Location in One Night (Theater or Jail):

  • $180 for an investigation up to 6 people for 5 hours
  • $35 per person for every additional person over 6 people
  • $50 per hour for each additional hour over 5 hours

Both Locations in One Night (Theater and Jail):

  • $210 for an investigation up to 6 people for 5 hours
  • $40 per person for every additional person over 6 people
  • $50 per hour for each additional hour over 5 hours

All Locations

  • Maximum 10 during the COVID-19 Outbreak
  • Requires one volunteer either from the theater board or 765 Paranormal (our local investigation partner)
    • Investigations are limited to either Friday or Saturday evenings 
  • Theater:
      • Any investigation in the theater must wait until after the evening movie ends and clean up is complete (approximately 10:00 pm)
    • If there is a need to do a walk through and equipment setup in the theater earlier, we may be able to accommodate before the doors open for the evening movie
    • Snacks are available for purchase
  • Jail:
    • Start times are negotiable
    • No air conditioning or heat, but we have electricity
    • No restroom facilities

To hold an agreed upon date and time requires a $90 deposit and is only refundable with 7 days advance notice to the investigation date. Full payment is due 7 days in advance. Call or email today to learn more. Payments can also be sent via US mail ahead of time, but will not be confirmed until payment is received.


Investigation Fees
Include Contact/Group Name



Follow the social media accounts of “My Haunted Fowler” to see the latest evidence captures:

Freak-Out at the Fowler CANCELLED

Best of the Fowler Theatre